Florida Stone Crab Claws With Mustard Sauce

Stone Crab season opened October 15 and runs through May 15. The Florida stone crab is a delicacy known around the world. They have a sweet taste and perfect texture. Florida stone crabs are found along the Atlantic and Gulf Coasts but are commercially harvested almost entirely in Florida.

Stone crabs differ from blue crabs in that only the oversized claws are harvested. Fishermen remove the claw and return the crab to the ocean. The crab will regenerate its claws. In fact, Florida law forbids the landing of whole stone crabs. Fishermen are allowed to take claws at least 2 3/4 inches long and are required to return stone crabs safely to the water. The stone crab can regenerate its claws three to four times, making it a renewable resource and a favorite among conservationists.

The sweet-tasting meat of Florida stone crab claws is delicious unseasoned, with melted butter or with a mustard sauce. The meat resembles lobster in appearance and flavor.

Cook the claws whole, with the shell on. Once cooked, the best way to crack the shell is to use a mallet or a hammer. Remove all of the cracked shell pieces, leaving the meat attached to the movable pincer. Don’t forget there’s plenty of delicious meat in the knuckles. The meat can also be picked from the claws and used as an ingredient in other recipes. Approximately 2.5 pounds of cooked stone crab claws yield one pound of meat.

The sweet-tasting meat of Florida Stone Crab claws is delicious unseasoned, with melted butter or with a mustard sauce. If you’ve ever been to Joe’s Stone Crab Restaurant in Miami and enjoyed their mustard sauce, you know it’s good! Now you can make it at home with this recipe.

Stone crab claws

1 tablespoon Colman’s dry mustard, or more to taste

1 cup mayonnaise

2 teaspoons Worcestershire

1 teaspoon A-1 sauce

2 tablespoons light cream


Heat a pot of water with a small pinch of salt. Place stone crab claws in a steamer basket and lower into the pot of boiling water with the pot covered. The crab claws should stay in the pot for for 5 or 6 minutes.

Once removed, you can serve the claws hot, or put them on ice to chill for 45 minutes to serve cold.


Place the mustard in a mixing bowl or the bowl of an electric mixer. Add the mayonnaise and beat for 1 minute.

Add the Worcestershire, A-1, cream, and a pinch of salt and beat until the mixture is well blended and creamy. If you’d like a little more mustardy bite, whisk in 1/2 teaspoon more dry mustard until well blended. Chill the sauce, covered, until serving.

Lighthouse Seafood is a family business,
owned and operated by Tim, Heather and Danny O’Leary.
They have supplied Central Florida restaurants and residents
with prime seafood for more than a decade.
Their commitment is to always have
only the freshest seafood for your table.

101 N. Country Club Rd.
Lake Mary, FL 32746

8780 E CR 466
The Villages, FL 32162